Alternative Titles/Edition History:
(1st Edition, 2013; 2nd Edition, 2015; 2+ Edition, 2017; 3rd Edition, 2020)
Publisher/Date:
Le Franc Tireur (1st Edition, 2013; 2nd Edition, 2015; 2+ Edition, 2017; 3rd Edition, 2020)
Product Type:
Accessory
Country of Origin:
France
Contents:
1st Edition (blue cover): 28-page spiral-bound booklet (with laminated cover) of ASL charts/tables
2nd Edition (blue cover): 36-page spiral-bound booklet of ASL charts/tables (no laminated cover)
2+ Edition (green cover): 36-page spiral-bound booklet of ASL charts/tables (no laminated cover).
3rd Edition (orange cover), regular version: 52-page spiral-bound booklet of ASL charts/tables (no laminated cover).
3rd Edition (orange cover), premium version #1: 52-page spiral-bound booklet of ASL charts/tables (with laminated cover).
3rd Edition (orange cover), premium version #2: 52-page spiral-bound booklet of ASL charts/tables (with laminated cover and laminated To Hit/To Kill charts pages).
Commentary:
Note: the DM High Recommendation Tag applies to the 2nd Edition, 3rd Edition and later booklets, not the 1st Edition booklet.
Go Straight to the Most Recent (3rd Edition) Comments
LFT surprised the ASL world in the summer of 2013 by venturing into the world of play aids. This is a realm of ASL that third party publishers rarely exploit (one recent exception was Countersmith Workshop, but they seem to have become inactive), though it is probably ripe for exploitation. MMP itself has never had any interest in ASL play aids or accoutrements, leaving an open field for those with initiative.
One third party publisher with initiative is LFT, which proved it by releasing what it calls the LFT Rat Pocket Charts, the “rat” apparently being a reference to LFT’s mascot, Rat Barricades. The Pocket Charts are an extremely useful ASL play aid, consisting of most of the main ASL charts and tables combined together in a half-page (long-wise) laminated, spiral-bound booklet. This format is far less bulky and far easier to use than the traditional ASL charts in a three-ring binder. It really is an improvement over the official charts in most respects (see below).
Here is a page-by-page list of what charts and tables are included (2016 note: 2nd Edition info added). Note that one flaw in the Pocket Charts is that it has no page numbers or index, so you have to flip through the whole thing until you find the chart you want. If this is ever re-printed, the booklet needs page numbers and an index (which can easily go on the essentially blank final page).
| Page Number | Charts and Tables (First Edition) | (Second Edition) |
| 1 | IFT | same |
| 2 | IIFT (boo) | same |
| 3 | Ambush, Leader Creation, Heat of Battle, Close Combat Table | same |
| 4 | Concealment Loss/Gain | same |
| 5 | Sniper Attack, Concealment drm, Searching | same, plus MF/PP Chart |
| 6 | Nationalities Capabilities Charts | National Capabilities Charts |
| 7 | OBA Firepower Chart, Control Chart | National Capabilities Charts |
| 8 | Terrain Effects Chart | National Capabilities Charts |
| 9 | Terrain Effects Chart | National Capabilities Charts |
| 10 | OBA Flowchart | National Capabilities Charts |
| 11 | OBA Flowchart | Support Weapons Chart, OBA Firepower Chart, Control Chart |
| 12 | OBA Flowchart | Terrain Effects Chart |
| 13 | OBA Flowchart | Terrain Effects Chart |
| 14 | To Hit Table, AP To Kill Table | Terrain Effects Chart |
| 15 | To Hit Table DRMs (continued), APCR/APDS To Kill Table, HE & Flame To Kill Table, AFV Destruction Table | Railroad Movement Costs Chart, Original/Colored dr IN DR Summary, Kindling Attempt |
| 16 | LATW To Kill Table, Acquisition Loss, Critical Hits, Gun Manhandling Number Modifications, Improbable Hits, Obtaining Modified TK# | Original 12 DR Summary, Original Doubles DR Summary, Original 11 DR Summary, Original 2 DR Summary |
| 17 | DC Placement vs. AFV DR, Unarmored Vehicle Destruction Table, Target Facing, HE Equivalency, Indirect Fire vs. AFV DRM, Obtaining Final TK #, Multiple Hits, Location of Vehicular Hit | Rubble Creation by HE Attack, Clearance Attempts & DRM, Kindling Numbers, Environmental Conditions, Spreading Fire DRM, HE Fires, Spreading Fire, Wind Change, Wind Force |
| 18 | Overrun Flowchart | To Hit Table, AP To Kill Table, HEAT To Kill Table |
| 19 | Overrun Flowchart | To Hit Table DRMs (continued), APCR/APDS To Kill Table, HE & Flame To Kill Table, AFV Destruction Table |
| 20 | Non-Terrain Related Vehicular MP Expenditures, Anti-Tank Magnetic Mine, Bog Check DRM, Canister FP, Excessive Speed Breakdown DRM, Bog Removal, HD Maneuver Attempt | LATW ranges, Acquisition Loss, Obtaining Modified TK#, Gun Manhandling, PF Chart, Target Facing, Location of Vehicular Hit |
| 21 | Beach Terrain | DC Placement vs. AFV DR, Unarmored Vehicle Destruction Table, HE Equivalency, Indirect Fire vs AFV IFT DRM, Multiple Hits, Obtaining Final TK (Aerial) |
| 22 | Glider Crash dr, Sighting TC DRM, Jitter Fire, Interrogation Table, Civilian Interrogation, Recon drm | OBA Flowchart |
| 23 | Night Rules (various) | OBA Flowchart |
| 24 | Desert Terrain Effects Chart | OBA Flowchart |
| 25 | Hammada Immobilization DR, Sand Bog DR, Desert VP, Misc. Desert Rules | OBA Flowchart |
| 26 | PTO Terrain Effects Chart | Overrun Flowchart |
| 27 | PTO Terrain Effects Chart, Tank-Hunter Hero ATMM, Tank-Hunter Hero Creation, PTO Date-Dependent Rules | Overrun Flowchart |
| 28 | (nothing) | ATMM, Non-Terrain Related Vehicular Expenditures, ESB DRM, Canister FP, Bog Check DRM, Bog Removal, HD Maneuver Attempt |
| 29 | — | Beach Terrain |
| 30 | — | Glider Crash dr, Sighting TC DRM, Jitter Fire, Interrogation Table, Civilian Interrogation, Recon drm |
| 31 | — | Night Rules (various) |
| 32 | — | Desert Terrain Effects Chart |
| 33 | — | Hammada Immobilization DR, Sand Bog DR, Desert VP, Misc. Desert Rules |
| 34 | — | PTO Terrain Effects Chart |
| 35 | — | PTO Terrain Effects Chart, Tank-Hunter Hero ATMM, Tank-Hunter Hero Creation, PTO Date-Dependent Rules |
| 36 | — | (nothing) |
The Pocket Charts are not without flaws or issues. One is essentially unfixable–the charts are typically smaller than they appear in their official form and therefore sometimes less readable. Another problem, for Americans, is that the chart booklet (based on European paper sizes) is too long. This is theoretically fixable (for future versions)–the pages can be cut down a bit without really affecting the presentation–but given that the publisher is European, LFT is unlikely ever to do so.
One issue for some will be that the charts are essentially organized not by frequency of use but by rulebook chapter. This is why, for example, the To Hit and To Kill tables, among the most used charts in ASL, are buried deep in the booklet (pages 14-15). Or why the PTO tables appear at the very end, after the Night Rules tables. One of the few advantages of the official charts and tables is that one can arrange the various fold-out cardstock inserts in whatever way one wanted. Here one is essentially forced to use the organization mandated by IFT. The lack of an index increases the problem.
Another issue is that opportunities for improvement were sometimes overlooked. For example, the Terrain Effects Chart simply repeats the “official” TEC’s order of terrain, an order that is not alphabetical, as it should be, but uselessly dependent on the arbitrary order the terrain is presented in Chapter B (which no one remembers). They missed a great chance to improve upon the original.
The reason why there are few improvements or changes to the charts stems from the Pocket Charts’ biggest and most controversial issue. The vast majority of the charts and tables are simply scanned versions of the official charts and tables. Though LFT has the capability to lay out its own versions of these charts and tables, they chose not to. They reproduced the official AH/MMP tables lock, stock and barrel, opening up various legal and/or ethical issues. Moreover, a few of the scanned tables weren’t even well-scanned. This gives a few of the pages a somewhat shoddy look.
The appropriation and reproduction of the official charts and tables adds an unpleasant aspect to what would otherwise be a definitely positive addition to the ASL world. What really needs to happen is for LFT to create a new, “2nd Edition” version of these charts, that would include an index (and perhaps some re-ordering), should look for areas to improve upon the original charts and tables, and most importantly, would contain original renderings of these charts and tables rather than scans of the originals. If LFT could do that, they would be doing many ASLers a solid service, because the idea of a laminated booklet of charts and tables is a very good one.
2nd Edition Comments: About a year and a half or so after the release of the LFT Rat Pocket Charts, LFT released a second edition with some noteworthy changes. This was something LFT had planned for some time, responding to criticisms (constructive and otherwise) and suggestions from people in the ASL community.
There are a number of changes in the second edition, most important among them the fact that all of the charts and tables seem to be of original composition rather than, as in the first edition, scanned from official MMP charts and tables. This is really important to anyone who wants to purchase ethical third party products.
The second major change is that the lamination is gone (the LFT website says that the cover is still laminated, but it is not). This is not a major issue but it may concern some. The pages of the booklet are actually sturdy cardstock and so can take a lot of wear and tear. However, the inclusion of tabs (see below) does introduce a bit of extra vulnerability. Players who think they will frequently use these charts might want to consider purchasing more than one, to have a spare (especially considering these come from a European third party publisher).
The third change is that the booklet is thicker, in that it is 36 pages long, rather than the 28 pages of the original booklet. In other words, there is more content in the second edition than in the first, including expanded national capabilities charts (including the revised Finns) and terrain charts, as well as a number of new charts (see table, above, for complete list and comparison with first edition).
A number of the tables and charts have been improved, either in layout, look, or content. Chief among these is the Terrain Effects chart, which now comes with all of the (ETO) terrain in alphabetical order rather than the useless (and functionally random) order that it appears on the official terrain chart. This was a suggestion made by Desperation Morale.
With all that content, how do you find the chart you are looking for? This was something of a problem in the first edition, which had no page numbers and no index. The second edition still has no page numbers and no index. These are really needed (a list of charts would fit on the back cover), because it is very easy to flip two pages at once and miss the chart you were looking for (indeed, when this author was counting the pages of the booklet, he had to count four times before he got an accurate count, because it is so easy to turn over multiple cardstock pages at once).
However, the second edition does have one addition which helps to some degree: it contains color-coded tabs that can take you straight to certain charts (such as the all-important To Hit & To Kill charts). This is very handy, although the tabs will get worn over time. However, there are still a number of charts that are hidden away in non-intuitive places where one would never think to look for them (for example, the Original doubles, 2, 11, and 12 charts are hidden away in the green “terrain/Chapter B” section, and the Kindling Attempt chart is two pages away from all the other Kindling & Spreading tables). So page numbers and a list of contents are still needed.A couple of ASLers have cut notches into the tabs to make all the pages easier to get to.
Some of the tables and charts would also benefit from additional minor improvements. For example, the IFT chart on the front of the booklet would benefit by a larger, bold and more visible FP line (this author has already had several opponents attempting to use the Vehicle line against him), or even have the Vehicle line moved to the bottom (as in the Desperation Morale version of the IFT).
Lastly, there are errors in some of the charts. This was virtually inevitable, given that new versions of all of the previously scanned charts and tables were created–even eagle-eyed proofreading would miss one or two items. However, no list of errata has been released yet (nor sticky errata created), which is a bit of a problem.
Despite these imperfections, the 2nd Edition Rat Pocket Charts are an excellent product and well worth a purchase. They could probably use a 3rd Edition to fix the errata and make the charts error-free, but the 2nd Edition Charts are usable (and more ethical than the first edition charts). If there ever is a third edition, hopefully LFT will change the color of the front/back covers to something other than blue, in order to make different editions more easily distinguishable from each other–the 1st and 2nd editions are too similar looking and an owner of both editions could easily grab the wrong one if not careful. The 2nd Edition charts are a Desperation Morale recommended product.
2+ Edition Comments: In 2017, LFT released a revised version of their second edition Rat Pocket Charts, distinguishable from previous versions by having a green cover instead of a blue cover. It basically incorporated errata discovered in the previous version (although it did introduce at least one mistake of its own).
In 2020, based on the feedback offered by many users, as well as the release by MMP of Forgotten War: Korea: 1950-1953, LFT decided to release an expanded third edition of its popular Rat Pocket Charts. The third edition is easily distinguished from previous editions by its orange color. Like the second edition, the 3rd Edition Rat Charts consist of a spiral-bound set of glossy, color thick-cardstock pages featuring various charts and tables for use with ASL. They are color coded and tabbed for ease of use. There is also a block of white space on the upper right front of the charts, which may be intended as a place for people to write their names, as it is not that difficult to accidentally walk off with someone else’s chart set, thinking it is your own.
Experience has shown that the Rat Charts hold up to wear and tear pretty well, although the corners and tabs can suffer somewhat. However, for the 3rd Edition, LFT has tried something new. It offers the Rat Charts in three different versions. First, the version as described above. Second, that version, except that the front and back covers have been laminated for additional protection. And third, as above, except that the To Hit/To Kill chart pages have also been laminated (presumably because they are among the most-referenced). This is a nice and thoughtful idea, one that many ASLers will appreciate, BUT having three different versions can be a little confusing, especially as some online resellers don’t stock all versions (nor may they even let people know there are multiple versions available). So it is possible for someone to buy the regular version, only later to learn that there are two “premium” versions also available. Or one may see someone else’s premium version, think that is the only version, and end up mistakenly purchasing the regular version thinking they were going to get a premium version.
So, bottom line, this is a good thing, but make sure you know what version you want and what version you are purchasing! It doesn’t hurt to ask a seller to confirm the presence or lack of lamination.
The charts are now 52 pages in length. They include charts that previous editions didn’t, such as Naval OBA, the bombardment table, Stun/STUN/Shock/UK tables, weather charts, LC charts, etc. The To Hit and To Kill tables were moved up to page 4 & 5, presumably because they are so frequently used.
The included National Capabilities Charts were also expanded. Unfortunately, they were expanded to various types of variant/expansion counters introduced in LFT products, so there is unofficial third party stuff inserted into the National Capabilities Charts, which is very unfortunate, especially because they are not labeled as such. Moreover, some of them are not even labeled, so there is a whole anonymous section for what turns out to be a single German division, the Spanish “Blue” Division, simply because LFT did some variant counters for them. All of this is problematic. LFT is not official ASL. If it wanted to add a separate chart identifying its own counters, well, fine. But it should not be inserting its own variant stuff into charts purporting to contain official ASL content.
On another note, the nationalities do not appear in alphabetical order, so one has to flip through all of them to find what one is looking for. They begin with Germans, then Finns, then Axis Minor, then Hungarian, then Allied Minor, then Japanese, then Chinese, then American, then Soviet, then Partisan, then British, then finally French. That’s not even the original order of publication, nor it is Axis then Allies; it’s just random.
Finally, the 3rd Edition Rat charts include Forgotten War-related charts and tables, including a Korean War National Capabilities Chart, Korean War leader creation & heat of battle charts, a Human Bullet/Hero/Suicide Hero Creation chart, a Korean terrain chart, and a page of miscellaneous tables.
Your humble author probably would have preferred it if LFT had released a separate, Korean War only Rat Pocket set (which would have, for example, just one terrain chart instead of people having to go back and forth between multiple terrain charts). But this still works.
The one key thing still missing from the Rat Pocket Charts is an index that would list every chart and the page on which it appears.
Since their initial release, the Rat Pocket Charts have proved popular and enduring and are an accessory frequently seen at ASL events and tournaments. Your humble author tends to use four: one with his home ASL set, one with his travel ASL set, one in his writing nook (for use when composing Desperation Morale entries, etc.), and one as a back-up because you JUST. NEVER. KNOW.
Leave A Reply